
28.4 - 1.5 2025
Pharos Dane Filozofije
Stari Grad Philosophy Days
foto: vilma matulic
"Nasuprot Zlu"
"The Opposite of Evil"
































































































photos Vilma Matulic, Stan Coenders, click image

Nakon vrlo cijenjenih izdanja iz 2023. i 2024., s ponosom najavljujemo 3. Starogradske dane filozofije od 28. travnja do 1. svibnja 2025.: 30 filozofa pridružuje se intenzivnim diskursima i opisuje
'Nasuprot Zlu'
bez korištenja izraza Zlo kao reference
After the much appreciated 2023 and 2024 editions we are proudly announcing the 3rd Stari Grad Philosophy Days from 28 April till 1 May 2025: 30 philosophers join intensive discourses about the
'The Opposite of Evil'
without expressions of Evil as reference
(Scroll down for the full program)
With: (click on links to view abstracts)
Aldo Čavić - philosopher, poet (Croatia);
Áine Donnellan - Film, Media and Journalism, Storyteller, MB/MA (Denmark)
Ana Beguš - Ana Beguš, linguist, University of Primorska (Slovenija);
Andrej Detela - physicist, Inventor, Philosopher, Poet (Slovenija);
Dragan Novković - school of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science in Belgrade (Serbia); Hrvoje Jurić - Filozofskog fakulteta Sveučilišta u Zagrebu (Croatia);
Ibrahim Spahić - poet, organizer International Festival Sarajevo Winter (Bosnia);
Jan Defrančeski - Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences Zagreb;
Kiki Klimt - Arthouse College for Art;
Krešimir Mišak - Journalist, Na rubu znanosti/On the edge of science (Croatia);
Kristina Bojanovic - Humanistic Studies, University of Donja Gorica (Montenegro);
Laura Vrabec - Institute for Cosmoloy and Philosophy of Nasture, Križevci (Croatia)
Michael George - Department of Religious Studies, St. Thomas University, Fredericton, Canada;
Milosav Gudovic - Institut za proučavanje kršćanske tradicije (Slovenija);
Natalija Medojevic - Faculty of philosophy Banja Luka;
Nikolina Tomić - Faculty of Philosophy Banja Luka;
Petar Pavlović - Institute for Cosmology and Philosophy of Nature / Križevci (Croatia);
Rok Zavrtanik - Sanje Publishers (Slovenija);
Simon Ryle - Associate Professor at the University of Split, Croatia;
Stan Coenders - PureCranioRelaxation (Netherlands);
Tea Golob - Faculty of Information Studies (Slovenija);
Željko Šaric - Faculty of Philosophy Banja Luka (Bosnia-Herzegovina)
All abstracts and content remain under the authorship of the respective participants.For informastion about content please refer to the links provided in the participants' pages.
O Temi: Nasuprot zlu
Iako se ponekad čini da je zlo sveprisutno, da su mu korijeni metafizički, činjenica je da ono nije ontološko: zlo ne postoji u međuzvjezdanom prostoru kozmosa, niti u kvantnim silama mikrokozmosa.
Pa ipak, opreke zlu, koje opisujemo mnogim duboko dojmljivim nazivima, nisu u stanju pružiti odgovarajuću protutežu gotovo opipljivoj sili koju ispoljava riječ zlo. Zlo je, zajedno s njegovim oprekama, prisutno samo u svijetu čovjeka i samo ih čovjek pridaje svijetu koji ga okružuje.
Od početaka filozofije, kao i religije, problem zla, kao i odgovor, suprotstavljanje zlu, pronalaženje vrijednosti koje su mu opreka, postoje kao jedan od najvažnijih pitanja za ljudski život.
Treći Farski filozofski simpozij bit će posvećen raspravi o opreci zlu. Povijesne i suvremene odgovore na problem zla tražimo u otvorenoj i tolerantnoj raspravi, ne zaboravljajući da ga ljudi prepoznaju u mnogim manifestacijama ljudskog postojanja, ali stavljajući u raspravi naglasak na vrednote i putokaze kojima čovjek daje snažne i motivirajuće odgovore na zlo - o ljudskom stavu protiv zla.
Kao moto našeg trećeg simpozija uzimamo Hektorovićev kameni natpis iznad zahoda u njegovom dvorcu Tvrdalj:
SI TE NOSTI CUR SUPERBIS
Ako se poznaješ čemu se oholiš
About the Theme: The opposite of evil
Although sometimes it seems that evil is omnipresent, that its roots are metaphysical, the fact is that it is not ontological: evil does not exist in the interstellar space of the cosmos, nor in the quantum forces of the microcosm.
Evil's opposition, which we capture with many deeply impactful names, is incapable of providing adequate counterbalance to the almost palpable force that the word evil exerts. Evil, together with its opposition, is present only in the world of man, and only man gives them to the world that surrounds him.
From the beginnings of philosophy, as well as religion, the problem of evil, as well as the answer, the opposition to evil, finding values that stand against it, exist as one of the most important problems for human life.
The third Pharos Philosophy Symposium will be devoted to the discussion of resistance to evil. We seek historical and contemporary answers to the problem of evil to be presented in an open and tolerant discussion, not forgetting that people recognize it in many manifestations of human existence, but placing emphasis on the values and guideposts to which man gives a strong and motivating response to evil - on the human attitude against evil.
As the motto of our third symposium, we take Hektorović's stone inscription above the toilet in his Tvrdalj Castle:
SI TE NOSTI CUR SUPERBIS
"Know what you are and how can you then be proud?"
"If you truly know yourself, what place is there for conceit?"
ovanja nalaze se ovdje: sudjelovanje
Znanstveno govoreći, nema suprotnosti. Je li nemoguće opisati protivnika zla bez korištenja zla kao reference? Pitao sam okolo, nakon što sam ga sam riješio; pet ljudi je. Neki odmah, neki nakon procesa transformacije u njihovom razmišljanju o tome. Međutim, naravno, izazovni naziv se raspada; "suprotno" je opis koji pati od dokaza o postojanju i opisivanju suprotnosti zla bez korištenja zlata kao reference je kao opisivanje bijelog bez korištenja boje kao reference.
Stan Coenders, srpanj 2024, Stari Grad.
Scientifically speaking, there is no contradiction. Is it impossible to describe the adversary of evil without using evil as a reference? I asked around; five people did it. Some immediately, some after the transformation process in their thinking about it. However, of course, the challenging title falls apart; "opposite" is a description that suffers from evidence of existence, and to describe the opposite of evil without using evil as a reference is like describing white without using color as a reference. Stan Coenders, July 2024, Stari Grad.
O Pharos simpoziju i starogradskim danima filozofije
Dani filozofije u Starome Gradu na otoku Hvaru zamišljeni su kao prostor susreta, razmjene mišljenja i dijaloga između filozofa, studenata filozofije i ljubitelja filozofije na tragu tradicije grčkog, Sokratovskog symposiona, a u mjestu koje ima snažne antičke, grčke korijene i koje je Aristotelov vršnjak (današnji Stari Grad utemeljili su Grci s egejskog otoka Parosa kao svoju koloniju Faros 384. godine pr. Kr.). Pročitaj više >
About Pharos Symposium and Stari Grad Philosophy Days
The Pharos Philosophy Symposium in Stari Grad (Otok Hvar Croatia) is conceived as an open gathering place, where philosophers, philosophy students and fellow travelers share their ideas in the tradition of the Greek Socratic symposium. The single guiding principle of the symposium is to freely reflect and critically engage with differing ideas. Read more >
Program:
Program se može promijeniti - molimo provjeritek
The programme may be subject to change - please check
(workshop pinhole came
Sob./Sat. 26.4
18.00:
Projekcija filma Dječak i čaplja, red. Hayao Miyazaki
Kino Stari Grad, Slobodan ulaz
Film screening: The Boy and the Heron, directed by Hayao Miyazaki,
Stari Grad Cinema, Free Admission for all
Pon./Mon. 28.4
19.00:
Otvorenje simpozija i izložbe, Uroš Abram - Window view
Muzej Staroga Grada, Galerija Juraj Plančić
Symposium Welcome and exhibition opening, Uroš Abram - Window View
Stari Grad Museum, Gallery Juraj Plančić
Uto./Tue. 29.4
09:45 – 10:00
Projekcija filma Bojana Brecelja, „U moje ime“
Muzej Staroga Grada
Film screening: 'In My Name', by Bojan Brecelj
Stari Grad Museum
Uto./Tue. 29.4
Vrt palače Biankini / Biankini Palace Garden
10:00 – 12:00 diskursi / discourses - Moderator: Hrvoje Jurić
Hrvoje Jurić: „Misliti bez ili s onu stranu opozicija: dobro, neloše, nedobro, zlo“
Hrvoje Jurić: "Thinking without or with the opposite side: good, not bad, evil"
12:00 – 12:30 pauza / break
12:30 – 14:30 diskursi / discourses - Moderator: Hrvoje Jurić
Željko Šarić: „Problem zla i dobra kroz prizmu teorije evolucije: uvidi Deneta i Dokinsa“
Dragan Novković: „Ljudska misao kao izvor neizrečenog“
Dragan Novković: "Human thought as a source of the unspoken"
14:30 – 16:00 pauza / break
16:00 – 18:00 diskursi / discourses - Moderator: Hrvoje Jurić
Kristina Bojanović: „Pasivnost kao etički zahtjev“
Kristina Bojanović: "Passivity as an ethical requirement"
Krešimir Mišak: „Nasuprot zlu stoji neaktivnost“
Krešimir Mišák: "The opposite of evil is non-activity"
Uto./Tue. 29.4
20.00
Glazbeno poetska večer s Tinkarom Kovač & Uroš Cingesar
Musical Poetry evening with Tinkara Kovač and Uroš Cingesar
Crkva sv. Ivana / Church St.Ivan
Srij./wed. 30.4
Tvrdalj Petra Hektorovića / Garden Petar Hektorović
10:00 – 12:00 diskursi / discourses - Moderator: Petar Pavlović
Uvod: Petar Pavlović: „Znanje kao odsutnost zla“
Introduction by Petar Pavlovic: "Knowledge as the absence of evil"
Andrej Detela: „Djelatni sklad i ljepota kao oblici iskonskog dobra“
Andrej Detela: "Active harmony and beauty as forms of primordial good"
12:00 – 12:30 pauza / break
12:30 – 14:30 diskursi / discourses - Moderator: Petar Pavlović
Tea Golob: „Prema dobru u središte Zemlje: stvaranje novih narativa, širenje imaginarija“
Kiki Klimt: „“Neka nitko tko ne zna geometriju ne ulazi pod moj krov“
Kiki Klimt: "No one who doesn't know geometry comes under my roof"
14:30 – 16:00 pauza / break
16:00 – 18:00 diskursi / discourses - Moderator: Petar Pavlović
Milosav Gudović: „Apologija dobra u Poemi o velikom inkvizitoru F.M. Dostojevskog“
Milosav Gudović: "Apology of the good in the Poem about the great Inquisitor by F.M. Dostojevsky"
Srij./wed. 30.4
20:00
Zajednička večera Kod Damira
Jazz koncert
Čet./Thu. 01.5
10:00
Izlet u Starogradsko polje i prvomajski grah
Excursion to Stari Grad Plain and traditional 1st May bean stew, Optional
--
Napomena / Note:
Program se može promijeniti - molimo provjeritek
The programme may be subject to change - please check
Exhibition Ivana Petan - Song of the Earth - ceramics
Ivana Petan - Skulpture pod nazivom “Pjesma zemlje”